The Aletheia Project

Aletheia blog cover: is it rude to ask?: getting a second opinion without the guilt

“is it rude to ask?”: getting a second opinion without the guilt

You walk out of an appointment with an answer. Maybe it’s a diagnosis, maybe it’s “it’s nothing”, maybe it’s a treatment plan. And something in you goes: I’m not sure that’s right.

Then the second thought arrives straight after. Asking someone else would be rude. Like I’m saying they’re bad at their job.

Let’s deal with that second thought, because it stops a lot of young people from getting care that fits them.

a second opinion is a normal part of health care

A second opinion just means asking another qualified health professional to look at the same problem. It’s not a complaint. It’s not a fight. Doctors ask each other for input too; that’s part of what a referral is.

healthdirect, the Australian Government’s health information service, puts it plainly: don’t be afraid to ask your doctor to refer you to another specialist for a second opinion, and you have the right to ask for as many opinions or referrals as you want.

That’s not a loophole. It’s built into how care in Australia is meant to work. The Australian Charter of Healthcare Rights lists seven rights that apply everywhere health care is provided, from hospitals to your local GP: Access, Safety, Respect, Partnership, Information, Privacy and Give feedback. “Partnership” means you get to be involved in decisions about your own care. You can’t really be a partner if you’re not allowed to check.

when it might be worth asking

There’s no rule for when a second opinion is “allowed”. But some moments are worth paying attention to:

  • Your symptoms haven’t changed (or have got worse) after the plan you were given.
  • You were told it’s “just stress”, “just hormones” or “you’ll grow out of it”, and it’s still affecting school, sleep, sport or your social life.
  • You’re facing a big decision, like surgery, a long-term medication or stopping something important.
  • You didn’t feel heard, and you left with more questions than answers.
  • Your gut is telling you something’s been missed.

That last one counts. You live in your body every day. A doctor sees it for 15 minutes.

Asking for a second opinion isn’t saying “you’re wrong”. It’s saying “this matters enough to me to be sure”.

how it actually works

Seeing another GP. You don’t need a referral to see a GP. You can book with a different GP at the same clinic or a different clinic. If you’re 15 or older, you can have your own Medicare card, which makes booking on your own easier.

Seeing another specialist. This is where referrals come in. You can see a specialist without one, but healthdirect notes that Medicare won’t cover any of the cost if you do, and some specialists won’t see you without one. So the usual route is to ask your GP for a referral to a different specialist. GP referrals to specialists usually last 12 months.

Getting your information. The second doctor will be more useful if they can see what’s already been done. Under Australian privacy law you have a general right to ask for access to the health information a health service provider holds about you. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner says providers should usually respond within a reasonable period (it suggests 30 days), and they can charge a fee, but it can’t be excessive. Public hospitals are covered by state or territory laws instead.

what to actually say

Most of the awkwardness is not knowing the words. Here are some you can borrow.

To your current doctor:

  • “I’d feel more comfortable getting another opinion before I decide. Could you refer me to someone else?”
  • “This is still really affecting me. Is there a specialist who could take another look?”
  • “Could I get a copy of my test results to bring to another appointment?”

To the new doctor:

  • “I’ve already seen someone about this. I was told [what you were told], but I’m still [what’s happening]. I’d like a fresh look.”

You don’t have to explain yourself at length or apologise. A good doctor won’t be offended. If someone does react badly to a calm, reasonable request, that tells you something useful too.

what to bring

  • Any test results, scans or reports you have (or the name of the clinic or lab that did them).
  • A short timeline: when it started, what’s changed, what you’ve tried.
  • A list of medicines and doses.
  • Your questions, written down. Put the most important one first.
  • A support person, if that helps you feel steadier. You can ask them to wait outside for part of the appointment if you want some privacy.

What you can do

  • Name the doubt. Write one sentence about why you’re unsure. That’s your opening line.
  • Ask for copies. Request your results before you need them, so you’re not chasing them later.
  • Get the referral. If you want a specialist’s view, ask your GP to refer you so Medicare can help with the cost.
  • Remember it’s not either/or. You can keep your usual GP and still get another view.
  • Speak up if something feels wrong. “Give feedback” is one of your healthcare rights. You can raise concerns with the service directly.

Not sure where to start? You can call the healthdirect helpline on 1800 022 222 (NURSE-ON-CALL in Victoria) any time to talk it through with a registered nurse. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, Kids Helpline is on 1800 55 1800 and Lifeline on 13 11 14. In an emergency, call 000.

Your health is worth being sure about. Asking twice isn’t rude. It’s how you look after yourself.

In voice and solidarity,
The Aletheia Project

Sources

This post is general information, not medical advice. Talk to a health professional about your own situation.